Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Carey Albertine's avatar

Lean In is misleading and reductive. I just think this is a conversation for MEN and women. Why is your remedy a conversation with your daughter?what about your sons? If this is about prioritizing family, shouldn’t men and boys participate in a conversation about the realities of working and raising a family? Or are you suggesting that only women have to make trade-offs?

Carey Albertine's avatar

We can agree on this: "we have always overvalued the masculine way of being."

Workplaces are designed to benefit men. That's a choice we've made as a society. All people — not just women — would benefit from workplaces that are relational, where people's lives and boundaries are honored. And we've made the same choice about family: no paid leave, underfunded schools, caregivers — teachers, nurses, elder care — paid a fraction of what we pay college football coaches. We've made public health choices that directly produced the rise in obesity you cite. You blame women who work — yet another thing we're apparently supposed to feel bad about — while ignoring the societal decisions that actually caused the outcomes you're mourning.

I know a lot of women who work and parent at the same time (imagine!). None of them are "trying to be men." I haven't seen the 1980s Diane Keaton version of the working woman since, well, 1980. What counts as "work" here — just corporate work? What about doctors, academics, artists, scientists, writers, journalists? Which jobs are acceptable for women to pursue? We're not going to settle nature vs. nurture in a comment section, but I fundamentally disagree that wanting to engage, create, and achieve is wired only into male biology.

I agree with you that we owe our kids honesty about what our society actually costs them. Here's some conversations we could have.

Girls AND Boys — What will an 80-hour week cost your family, your health, your relationships?

Girls AND Boys — Look for a partner who wants to partner. Someone who values your interests, your drive, your ambition, and sees work and family as something you build together.

Girls AND Boys — Keep pushing for public policy that values community, family, and health. Look for workplaces with humane leaders. Be a leader who treats others with respect, kindness, and compassion.

Girls AND Boys — Respect people's choices about how they live, work, parent, and love, with humility. Respect your own choices too. There is no one right way — and anyone who tells you otherwise is trying to sell you something.

3 more comments...

Ready for more?